General Eric Smith, the commandant of the U.S. Marine Corps, highlighted that the combat experience of the U.S. military over the past two decades provides a significant advantage over China’s People’s Liberation Army (PLA). Speaking at the Reagan National Defense Forum, Smith emphasized the value of the U.S. military’s operational history and joint force capabilities compared to China’s lack of recent large-scale combat engagements.
Key Points from General Smith’s Remarks:
1. Comparison of Combat Experience:
• Smith underscored the extensive combat history of U.S. forces in Iraq and Afghanistan, which has sharpened their ability to adapt and operate effectively in high-pressure environments.
• In contrast, China’s most recent war—the brief and costly conflict with Vietnam in 1979—is decades old, and modern operational experience is notably absent in the PLA.
2. Interoperability and Joint Operations:
• Smith emphasized the joint force culture in the U.S. military, developed over years of cooperation between branches like the Army, Navy, Air Force, and Marines.
• He pointed out that China has not yet demonstrated similar capabilities or the ability to operate seamlessly as a joint force.
3. Real-World Preparedness:
• The general dismissed China’s rhetoric, suggesting that actual combat experience is far more valuable than exercises or theoretical planning.
• He remarked, “It is easy to bluster, but it’s another thing when you actually have to go toe-to-toe and go in harm’s way.”
China’s Military Development:
While Smith downplayed China’s operational readiness, the PLA has significantly modernized its military over the past two decades. Key developments include:
1. Increased Naval Capabilities:
• The PLA Navy now has the largest fleet in the world, including modern aircraft carriers and advanced submarines.
2. Advanced Technology:
• Investments in artificial intelligence, hypersonic weapons, and cyber warfare are areas where China seeks to close the gap with the U.S.
3. Regional Dominance:
• Regular military exercises in the South China Sea and near Taiwan showcase the PLA’s ambitions to project power regionally.
However, the lack of recent combat experience raises questions about how effectively these capabilities would translate in a real-world conflict.
Implications of Smith’s Comments:
1. Confidence in U.S. Military:
• Smith’s remarks aim to reassure allies and deter adversaries by emphasizing the U.S. military’s operational superiority and proven track record.
2. Potential Miscalculation:
• While combat experience is an advantage, underestimating China’s modernized military capabilities or readiness could lead to miscalculations in strategic planning.
3. Emphasis on Readiness:
• Smith’s comments reinforce the importance of maintaining combat readiness and interoperability, especially as tensions rise in the Indo-Pacific region.
EVP/Founder @JTSi - Government Prime Contractor
6moCongrats!