What do you think?
Rate this book
The Rose Bargain
The Cruel Prince meets The Selection in this captivating duology opener brimming with heart-pounding romance, vicious competition, and beautiful, cruel fae, from the New York Times bestselling author of The Witch Haven, Sasha Peyton Smith.
Every citizen of England is granted one bargain from their immortal fae queen.
High society girls are expected to bargain for qualities that will win them suitors: a rare talent for piano in exchange for one’s happiest childhood memory. A perfect smile for one’s ability to taste.
But Ivy Benton’s debut season arrives with a shocking twist: a competition to secure the heart of the Queen’s fae son, Prince Bram. A prize that could save Ivy’s family from ruin… and free her sister from the bargain that destroyed her.
Yet every glittering fae deal has a rotting heart—and at the center of this contest is a dark plot that could destroy everything Ivy knows.
Sweepingly romantic and deceptively enchanting, this alternate history romantasy will enthrall readers of Holly Black, Stephanie Garber, and Adalyn Grace.
Every citizen of England is granted one bargain from their immortal fae queen.
High society girls are expected to bargain for qualities that will win them suitors: a rare talent for piano in exchange for one’s happiest childhood memory. A perfect smile for one’s ability to taste.
But Ivy Benton’s debut season arrives with a shocking twist: a competition to secure the heart of the Queen’s fae son, Prince Bram. A prize that could save Ivy’s family from ruin… and free her sister from the bargain that destroyed her.
Yet every glittering fae deal has a rotting heart—and at the center of this contest is a dark plot that could destroy everything Ivy knows.
Sweepingly romantic and deceptively enchanting, this alternate history romantasy will enthrall readers of Holly Black, Stephanie Garber, and Adalyn Grace.
400 pages, Hardcover
First published February 4, 2025
1,155 people are currently reading
63.9k people want to read
About the author
Sasha Peyton Smith
4 books1,202 followersSasha Peyton Smith is the New York Times best selling author of The Witch Haven and The Witch Hunt. She’s passionate about well-curated road trip playlists, soup recipes, and stories about complicated girls. Originally from Utah, she now lives in Washington D.C. with her partner and collection of porcelain hands.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,157 reviews
February 7, 2025
➸ 3.5 stars
𓍢⊹ ࣪ thank you to netgalley and the publishers for the advanced readers copy!
✨ marriage competition
🌹 minor trials
✨ forbidden love
🌹 faerie bargains
✨ high society 1848 london
this was such a fun read! it was really easy to read and i flew through it! immediately from chapter one i was utterly obsessed with the banter between ivy and emmet and it was such a promising start to the book!
overall, things kind of just fell from there for me. i still don’t know what to think of ivy, the fmc, i just don’t have much thoughts there! i did like emmet, mostly because of the dynamic between him and ivy HOWEVER i felt like there was no build up which made me not really see a connection between them!
ALSO, authors and getting quite bold these days sneaking in fully detailed smut chapters in YOUNG ADULT novels!!! what happened to fade to black???? a warning of explicit content at the start would be nice to have for the younger readers out there at least!
i also felt like the stakes weren’t high; the trials were boring and overall i felt like nothing exciting was happening… UNTIL THE END!!!! i did like the twist at the end and i kind of saw it coming but it was nice having a oh my god this really just happened moment and im definitely looking foward to book two!!
i wish we could’ve gotten more of the side characters and their stories! i absolutely loved their povs and i found them all so intriguing!! GREER DESERVED BETTER. anyways, i hope to see more of them as they have some amazing stories for their characters and i really loved the friendships they found with each other!!
“When one makes a faerie bargain, one must be prepared to pay the price. There is one silver lining. I have nothing to lose.”
𓍢⊹ ࣪ thank you to netgalley and the publishers for the advanced readers copy!
✨ marriage competition
🌹 minor trials
✨ forbidden love
🌹 faerie bargains
✨ high society 1848 london
this was such a fun read! it was really easy to read and i flew through it! immediately from chapter one i was utterly obsessed with the banter between ivy and emmet and it was such a promising start to the book!
overall, things kind of just fell from there for me. i still don’t know what to think of ivy, the fmc, i just don’t have much thoughts there! i did like emmet, mostly because of the dynamic between him and ivy HOWEVER i felt like there was no build up which made me not really see a connection between them!
ALSO, authors and getting quite bold these days sneaking in fully detailed smut chapters in YOUNG ADULT novels!!! what happened to fade to black???? a warning of explicit content at the start would be nice to have for the younger readers out there at least!
i also felt like the stakes weren’t high; the trials were boring and overall i felt like nothing exciting was happening… UNTIL THE END!!!! i did like the twist at the end and i kind of saw it coming but it was nice having a oh my god this really just happened moment and im definitely looking foward to book two!!
i wish we could’ve gotten more of the side characters and their stories! i absolutely loved their povs and i found them all so intriguing!! GREER DESERVED BETTER. anyways, i hope to see more of them as they have some amazing stories for their characters and i really loved the friendships they found with each other!!
March 15, 2025
WHAT A GREAT BOOK!!! 🌷💖🎀
A BEAUTIFUL READ, JUST LIKE ITS BEAUTIFUL COVER! 💍🌹😼
If you’re a fan of Stephanie Garber and Holly Black, then read it IMMEDIATELY…😘
FINALLY, a lovely fantasy read after so long! 🤗
Ivy Benton is such a fierce FMC and very strong. 🥹 I loved her tactics, and ahh—I absolutely adore her! 🤭🙂↕️ She is such a beautifully written character.
Prince Emmett De Vere 🙂↕️ MY SHAYLAAAAA!!! I loved him from his first appearance in the book, and my love for him grew after reading this scene:
“His eyebrows are furrowed, his mouth screwed up in a scowl, his hands balled into white-knuckled fists. Standing completely still, staring at me like he absolutely loathes me, is Prince Emmett De Vere.”
AHHHHHH!!! I’M NOT SQUEALING (YES, I AM). 😆🤭
And Prince Bram, pls die. 🥰
(Sorry for thinking good things about you. 😒)
Also, the other girls 👀—I’m impressed, though. I can’t wait to read more about their teamwork.🎀💖🌷 SO LOVELY 🥹🥹
I NEED BOOK 2. RN. MY IMPATIENT AHH CAN’T WAIT! 😭
Okay, Emmett's scenes always made me feel so good and 🦋🦋🦋 (👀). From the first scene until the end. My poor boy didn’t deserve that ending 🫠. But yes, I’m rooting for Ivy and the girls to save him and Lydia (oooh, I love her too. Well, ig atp I love everyone except Bram). I loved the banter between Ivy and Emmett so much. OMG 🤭! Fictional characters… you guys are my obsession fr. 😩
At first, I liked the interaction between Ivy and Bram (pls die🥰) too, but now I loathe him, and I feel so silly for thinking Bram was a golden retriever. 😃 (Forgive me.)
YES, THAT’S ALL. ✌️ (EMMETT, OH EMMETT, I LOVE YOU! *shrimp with a heart on its head* IYKYK 👀)
____________________________
Pre-read
FINALLYYYYYY…. I’M SO EXCITED 🌷🎀😆
ALSO THE COVER HELLOOOO!?!? 👀 SOOOO PRETTY OMG🌷🎀💖🩷
A BEAUTIFUL READ, JUST LIKE ITS BEAUTIFUL COVER! 💍🌹😼
If you’re a fan of Stephanie Garber and Holly Black, then read it IMMEDIATELY…😘
FINALLY, a lovely fantasy read after so long! 🤗
Ivy Benton is such a fierce FMC and very strong. 🥹 I loved her tactics, and ahh—I absolutely adore her! 🤭🙂↕️ She is such a beautifully written character.
Prince Emmett De Vere 🙂↕️ MY SHAYLAAAAA!!! I loved him from his first appearance in the book, and my love for him grew after reading this scene:
“His eyebrows are furrowed, his mouth screwed up in a scowl, his hands balled into white-knuckled fists. Standing completely still, staring at me like he absolutely loathes me, is Prince Emmett De Vere.”
AHHHHHH!!! I’M NOT SQUEALING (YES, I AM). 😆🤭
And Prince Bram, pls die. 🥰
(Sorry for thinking good things about you. 😒)
Also, the other girls 👀—I’m impressed, though. I can’t wait to read more about their teamwork.🎀💖🌷 SO LOVELY 🥹🥹
I NEED BOOK 2. RN. MY IMPATIENT AHH CAN’T WAIT! 😭
Okay, Emmett's scenes always made me feel so good and 🦋🦋🦋 (👀). From the first scene until the end. My poor boy didn’t deserve that ending 🫠. But yes, I’m rooting for Ivy and the girls to save him and Lydia (oooh, I love her too. Well, ig atp I love everyone except Bram). I loved the banter between Ivy and Emmett so much. OMG 🤭! Fictional characters… you guys are my obsession fr. 😩
At first, I liked the interaction between Ivy and Bram (pls die🥰) too, but now I loathe him, and I feel so silly for thinking Bram was a golden retriever. 😃 (Forgive me.)
YES, THAT’S ALL. ✌️ (EMMETT, OH EMMETT, I LOVE YOU! *shrimp with a heart on its head* IYKYK 👀)
____________________________
Pre-read
FINALLYYYYYY…. I’M SO EXCITED 🌷🎀😆
ALSO THE COVER HELLOOOO!?!? 👀 SOOOO PRETTY OMG🌷🎀💖🩷
February 5, 2025
This book immerses readers into a world where the familiar merges with the fantastical—a reimagined 1840s England where a faerie queen holds sway over the realm, and every citizen is offered one life-altering bargain. Set against this richly atmospheric backdrop, the story centers around Ivy Benton, a young woman from a once-prominent family now teetering on the brink of ruin. With her sister bound by a devastating fae bargain and her family's future at stake, Ivy finds herself thrust into a competition to win the heart of the fae prince, Bram. But as she ventures deeper into the glittering, dangerous world of faerie bargains, she quickly discovers that the true cost of victory might be more than she ever imagined.
Smith masterfully blends elements of historical fiction with dark fantasy, creating a vibrant world that feels both familiar and otherworldly. The courtly intrigue, vicious competition, and Ivy’s tangled relationships lend a gripping tension to the narrative, while the presence of eerie fae magic adds an unsettling layer that keeps readers on edge. The romantic elements are delicately woven into the plot, with Ivy caught between two brothers in a love triangle that, while somewhat predictable, still manages to tug at the heartstrings.
One of the standout aspects of the novel is Ivy’s relationship with her sister, Lydia, which forms a core emotional thread throughout the book. Their bond is both tender and fraught, reflecting the difficult choices that must be made when family and loyalty are tested by forces beyond their control. As Ivy navigates the cutthroat competition and the mysteries of the fae court, her determination and resilience shine through, even as she grapples with the moral consequences of the bargains she encounters.
While the story is undeniably engaging, it does falter in a few places. The romantic subplot, while sweet, sometimes feels rushed, lacking the deeper development that would have made Ivy's emotional journey more compelling. Additionally, the competition itself, which is central to the plot, could have been expanded to heighten the stakes and deepen the dynamics between the characters. More games, more tension, and a greater exploration of the fae queen’s eerie influence would have added a sharper edge to the story.
Despite these shortcomings, The Rose Bargain is an absorbing read for fans of fantasy romance, particularly those drawn to stories of fae bargains and courtly drama. With its unique premise and vivid world-building, the novel sets the stage for an exciting sequel that promises to delve even deeper into the mysteries and dangers of Ivy’s world. Smith’s ability to weave an enchanting yet perilous tale ensures that readers will be eagerly anticipating the next installment in this captivating duology.
Many thanks to NetGalley and HarperCollins Children's Books | HarperCollins for providing me this digital reviewer copy in exchange of my honest thoughts.
medium.com
instagram
facebook
twitter
Smith masterfully blends elements of historical fiction with dark fantasy, creating a vibrant world that feels both familiar and otherworldly. The courtly intrigue, vicious competition, and Ivy’s tangled relationships lend a gripping tension to the narrative, while the presence of eerie fae magic adds an unsettling layer that keeps readers on edge. The romantic elements are delicately woven into the plot, with Ivy caught between two brothers in a love triangle that, while somewhat predictable, still manages to tug at the heartstrings.
One of the standout aspects of the novel is Ivy’s relationship with her sister, Lydia, which forms a core emotional thread throughout the book. Their bond is both tender and fraught, reflecting the difficult choices that must be made when family and loyalty are tested by forces beyond their control. As Ivy navigates the cutthroat competition and the mysteries of the fae court, her determination and resilience shine through, even as she grapples with the moral consequences of the bargains she encounters.
While the story is undeniably engaging, it does falter in a few places. The romantic subplot, while sweet, sometimes feels rushed, lacking the deeper development that would have made Ivy's emotional journey more compelling. Additionally, the competition itself, which is central to the plot, could have been expanded to heighten the stakes and deepen the dynamics between the characters. More games, more tension, and a greater exploration of the fae queen’s eerie influence would have added a sharper edge to the story.
Despite these shortcomings, The Rose Bargain is an absorbing read for fans of fantasy romance, particularly those drawn to stories of fae bargains and courtly drama. With its unique premise and vivid world-building, the novel sets the stage for an exciting sequel that promises to delve even deeper into the mysteries and dangers of Ivy’s world. Smith’s ability to weave an enchanting yet perilous tale ensures that readers will be eagerly anticipating the next installment in this captivating duology.
Many thanks to NetGalley and HarperCollins Children's Books | HarperCollins for providing me this digital reviewer copy in exchange of my honest thoughts.
medium.com
February 13, 2025
I will be Bram's or I will be no one's.
And now the only thing I can do is live with it.
⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹
What kind of crack did Sasha Peyton Smith lace through the pages of The Rose Bargain? I can't believe I have to wait at least another year for the sequel to come. I need more. This was so addicting to read and I probably would've finished this sooner if I didn't have a full-time job.
If you want something to convince you to read this, I would say this book is definitely what it's marketed as: Folk of the Air trilogy meets Bridgerton, but also with a touch of The Selection. It takes place in 1848 Regency London but in a slightly alternate universe where a fae queen, Queen Mor, rules over England. The story follows Ivy Benton as she enters English society. All new ladies coming out in the new season get to make a bargain with Queen Mor to up their chances of finding a suitor, courting them, and getting married. However, the bargains don't come for free and usually come at the cost of things such as a lost finger, tooth, or no longer being able to dream. However, things are different this year, as Queen Mor's fae son Prince Bram is looking for a wife. Anyone who wishes to participate must compete for his hand, and anyone who doesn't or isn't chosen by Bram must never marry anyone else. Ivy, determined to restore her family's name and place in society, enters the competition for Bram's hand. She starts getting tips and lessons from Prince Emmett, Bram's human brother, to get to know Bram better, but what if something more develops?
This was a very fast and easy read! I liked the relationship between Ivy and the 5 other girls she was competing with, not to mention the cast of girls was diverse; Emmy Ito is Japanese, Marion Thorne's family is from Ghana, and there's LGBTQIA+ rep with Marion and Faith Fairchild (Faith is bisexual and Marion is lesbian). It started off very catty and snarky among them all since they were each other's competition, but as the plot continues and turns into something much darker than etiquette lessons and balls and outings, they band together and support each other to get themselves through the season and I loved how their loyalty and friendships with each other grew. I also thought Ivy's relationship with her sister, Lydia, was also interesting and I wish we got more of it throughout the story. Lydia is the reason why their family's name was stained since she made a bargain at her own coming out season 2 years prior but doesn't remember what she wanted. Ivy wants to find out what it is and undo it so her family isn't outcasted anymore.
The only two things I took a star off for were the love triangle and the random POVs of the other characters throughout the story. I didn't mind the love triangle--I usually hate them--but I felt there was no buildup to either ship at all. It wasn't until the end when I started rooting for one specific ship to become endgame and I feel like that's way too late into the story. I think Sasha Peyton Smith was trying to make the relationships ambiguous so you couldn't tell who Ivy wants, but some slow burn, angst, and tension would've been perfect in this book and I felt that was lacking.
As for the random POVs, we get to hear from the other girls in the competition, why they entered, what they bargained for, and what they really want. I thought it was cool and a nice touch to read about Ivy's friends and their thoughts on everything, but they all felt sort of randomly placed throughout the story to the point where it almost didn't make sense to even include them. I felt like there were two options: include ALL of the girls' POVs throughout the story (beyond just a chapter for each of them, anyway) as the plot progresses, or just keep Ivy as the sole narrator since she is the main character. We also get to hear from Lydia and Prince Emmett (and if you have the Barnes & Noble exclusive edition, there's an extra chapter from Emmett's POV at the end!). I think some more chapters from Emmett's POV would've been nice so I hope we get some of his POV in the next book. The banter between Emmett and Ivy as he essentially becomes her wingman? Absolutely hilarious. The scene where Emmett tries to teach Ivy how to flirt is comedy gold. ("We're doomed." ~Emmett de Vere)
(And can we talk about that ending for a second?! Like, WHAT WAS THAT?! That plot twist was better than some of the plot twists I've recently read in the THRILLERS I've finished and reviewed. I'll admit I didn't see that coming. Color me impressed.)
Overall, I LOVED The Rose Bargain and I think it's currently sitting at the top for my favorite read of February 2025. I'll be
4 stars
⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹⊹ ࣪ ˖ ꫂ ၴႅၴ ₊ ⊹
Disclaimer: The trigger warnings below may contain minor spoilers for the story. I ALWAYS include trigger warnings in my reviews because I feel like that's quite literally the bare minimum I should do when writing a review to make everyone aware of what they're getting into when starting a book. PLEASE protect your peace and mental health above all else; do what's best for you if there's something in a book that might make you uncomfortable.🤍 I've left a significantly large, intentional gap between this message and the trigger warnings so that if anyone wishes to know what they are to scroll a bit more.
Trigger warnings: memory loss, death of a loved one, bodily injuries, suspicions of/implied suicide, mentions of blood, self-harm for sacrificial purposes, murder
𝒫𝓇𝑒-𝓇𝑒𝒶𝒹: Starting another one of my 2025 most anticipated books! I'm so excited to read this. Also, if you were wondering why the cover is white and not pink, it's because I got the Barnes & Noble exclusive edition. It's SUPER pretty; there's an alternate cover and the case design is a bunch of gold roses and the endpapers are a painting of roses🤍✨🌹If you want to see what it looks like, you can see it here!
March 3, 2025
3.75⭐️
I haven’t read The Selection or The Cruel Prince in ages, so I can’t confidently speak to how similar this book is to them. The description mentions that it has elements of both, and from what little I remember, I can definitely see some of those influences.
I really liked how it started—there were questions right from the beginning, which kept me hooked until the end because I needed to see how everything unfolded. As the story progressed, the stakes kept rising. It became clear that this wasn’t just about a prince choosing a bride; it was a much bigger story about overthrowing tyranny and so on. It was a fun, interesting ride—not the most original story, but also not entirely predictable—about 50/50. The twists at the end were definitely enjoyable!
I loved the worldbuilding!! All the locations were real places in England and beyond, and the mix of real-world settings with a magical land helped keep my interest. I don’t see this done often, so I loved it!
The characters were okay—no one stood out to me in particular. However, I did like that almost everyone got a POV here and there, though most of it focused on Ivy. The romance didn’t completely pull me in—it was cute, but nothing that fully immersed me the way I prefer. On the other hand, I really enjoyed the friendships that developed between the girls, and their POVs made their intentions and dynamics feel even more meaningful.
Overall, I’m glad I picked this up! It was fun watching everything unfold, and after that ending, I’ll definitely be picking up the next book!
I haven’t read The Selection or The Cruel Prince in ages, so I can’t confidently speak to how similar this book is to them. The description mentions that it has elements of both, and from what little I remember, I can definitely see some of those influences.
I really liked how it started—there were questions right from the beginning, which kept me hooked until the end because I needed to see how everything unfolded. As the story progressed, the stakes kept rising. It became clear that this wasn’t just about a prince choosing a bride; it was a much bigger story about overthrowing tyranny and so on. It was a fun, interesting ride—not the most original story, but also not entirely predictable—about 50/50. The twists at the end were definitely enjoyable!
I loved the worldbuilding!! All the locations were real places in England and beyond, and the mix of real-world settings with a magical land helped keep my interest. I don’t see this done often, so I loved it!
The characters were okay—no one stood out to me in particular. However, I did like that almost everyone got a POV here and there, though most of it focused on Ivy. The romance didn’t completely pull me in—it was cute, but nothing that fully immersed me the way I prefer. On the other hand, I really enjoyed the friendships that developed between the girls, and their POVs made their intentions and dynamics feel even more meaningful.
Overall, I’m glad I picked this up! It was fun watching everything unfold, and after that ending, I’ll definitely be picking up the next book!
March 14, 2025
2.5 stars.
I’ll begin with the few things I liked, which were quite limited. Firstly, I appreciated the concept, but the execution fell flat. The first half of the book was enjoyable; it had a fun vibe, and if I managed to overlook the romance, it provided a pleasant reading experience. I genuinely thought this would turn into a four-star book because I loved that initial half. Marion Thorne stood out as the best character, and I wish she had been the protagonist.
Now, let’s dive into what I didn’t like, which is much more substantial. The pacing was chaotic. Events rushed by so quickly that I often felt disoriented. As for the characters, simply giving side characters POV chapters doesn’t mean you can skimp on developing their personalities. They were so flat that I struggled to keep track of who was who.
The friendship between the girls felt quite surface-level due to the lack of depth in the side characters.
The last half of the book was utterly ridiculous; I found myself laughing because it felt like a prank—there was no way what was happening could be taken seriously. And the romance? A complete disaster. If I can even label it as romance, it was the biggest factor that derailed the story for me. The relationship progressed so quickly that it felt like I was missing key scenes of the couple spending time together.
Emmett is an atrocious love interest, and surprisingly, even after everything, I still prefer Bram(though he was not much better). Why do authors persist in believing that all women are attracted to men with a playboy reputation? I find these kinds of male love interests to be so cringe-worthy. The situation with Faith only added to my dislike for him. We seemed to spend more time on his secret "love story" with Faith than with Ivy. I would have understood if Faith had been a likable character, but she really was not. Even after learning about her past, I still didn’t like her. The lack of chemistry between the main couple made this even worse.
Also, that sex scene.....why? That's all I want to ask...why?
Ivy was also frustratingly passive and went along with whatever everyone wanted, which made it hard for me to care about her after the first half.
In conclusion, if the story had focused solely on Ivy entering the contest out of a desire to gain power and beat the Fae at their own game, it could have been fantastic. Unfortunately, it was not.
I’ll begin with the few things I liked, which were quite limited. Firstly, I appreciated the concept, but the execution fell flat. The first half of the book was enjoyable; it had a fun vibe, and if I managed to overlook the romance, it provided a pleasant reading experience. I genuinely thought this would turn into a four-star book because I loved that initial half. Marion Thorne stood out as the best character, and I wish she had been the protagonist.
Now, let’s dive into what I didn’t like, which is much more substantial. The pacing was chaotic. Events rushed by so quickly that I often felt disoriented. As for the characters, simply giving side characters POV chapters doesn’t mean you can skimp on developing their personalities. They were so flat that I struggled to keep track of who was who.
The friendship between the girls felt quite surface-level due to the lack of depth in the side characters.
The last half of the book was utterly ridiculous; I found myself laughing because it felt like a prank—there was no way what was happening could be taken seriously. And the romance? A complete disaster. If I can even label it as romance, it was the biggest factor that derailed the story for me. The relationship progressed so quickly that it felt like I was missing key scenes of the couple spending time together.
Emmett is an atrocious love interest, and surprisingly, even after everything, I still prefer Bram(though he was not much better). Why do authors persist in believing that all women are attracted to men with a playboy reputation? I find these kinds of male love interests to be so cringe-worthy. The situation with Faith only added to my dislike for him. We seemed to spend more time on his secret "love story" with Faith than with Ivy. I would have understood if Faith had been a likable character, but she really was not. Even after learning about her past, I still didn’t like her. The lack of chemistry between the main couple made this even worse.
Also, that sex scene.....why? That's all I want to ask...why?
Ivy was also frustratingly passive and went along with whatever everyone wanted, which made it hard for me to care about her after the first half.
In conclusion, if the story had focused solely on Ivy entering the contest out of a desire to gain power and beat the Fae at their own game, it could have been fantastic. Unfortunately, it was not.
February 7, 2025
This story will reawaken the younger version of you that believed in fairies and have her kicking her feet and twirling around with a heart full of magic & wonder!!!!!🩰🫧🧚♀️🍃 This truly is The Cruel Prince x The Selection (and I would add x Bridgerton x The Infernal Devices)
If the ethereal vibes are what pulled me in, then the political fantasy, strong female relationships and soul-obliterating YEARNING is what had me locked in from the first to the last page.
There were SO many moments where I had to set the book down and blink at the wall in awe. There were quotes that hit me straight to my soul, friendship dynamics that were better than I ever could have dreamed and the ROMANCE!!!!!!!!! THE ROMANCE FELT LIKE LISTENING TO A LOVE SONG WRITTEN BY TAYLOR SWIFT FOR THE VERY FIRST TIME.
Ivy Benton…..you are the youngest daughter representation I have always craved. A soul girl forever.
If you like the following niche fangirlisms then you will ADORE this book:
-will herondale
-the triwizard tournament hedge maze
-everything about amy march
-barbie movies (and their soundtracks)
-BRIDGERTON ANGST
-jane and elizabeth bennett
-daydreaming about crossing the wardrobe into narnia
-victorian london
INFINITY STARS!!! THIS IS A SOUL STORY / CHARACTER / MOMENT♾️💗✨♾️💗✨
If the ethereal vibes are what pulled me in, then the political fantasy, strong female relationships and soul-obliterating YEARNING is what had me locked in from the first to the last page.
There were SO many moments where I had to set the book down and blink at the wall in awe. There were quotes that hit me straight to my soul, friendship dynamics that were better than I ever could have dreamed and the ROMANCE!!!!!!!!! THE ROMANCE FELT LIKE LISTENING TO A LOVE SONG WRITTEN BY TAYLOR SWIFT FOR THE VERY FIRST TIME.
Ivy Benton…..you are the youngest daughter representation I have always craved. A soul girl forever.
If you like the following niche fangirlisms then you will ADORE this book:
-will herondale
-the triwizard tournament hedge maze
-everything about amy march
-barbie movies (and their soundtracks)
-BRIDGERTON ANGST
-jane and elizabeth bennett
-daydreaming about crossing the wardrobe into narnia
-victorian london
INFINITY STARS!!! THIS IS A SOUL STORY / CHARACTER / MOMENT♾️💗✨♾️💗✨
Currently reading
March 12, 2025A society where all citizens are expected to make a Fae bargain? What could go wrong? 🙃
February 28, 2025
4.5 stars
i love a good fae story where they’re tricky and mischievous in the true nature of fairies. throw in a marriage competition with bridgerton vibes? yep, i’m so there.
this was fun and fast paced. i did struggle to get into at first, but i eventually found myself sucked into the story. i definitely preferred the second half and the last 10% had me biting my nails in nervous anticipation.
the romance was good but i felt like it needed more depth. it started slow and then built up really quickly and i don’t know where their feelings came from. everything else was amazing! i really enjoyed the friendships the girls formed throughout their time together and the trials they went through were interesting.
i love the direction it went and will without a doubt be gnawing at the bars of my enclosure for a second book🙂↕️
i love a good fae story where they’re tricky and mischievous in the true nature of fairies. throw in a marriage competition with bridgerton vibes? yep, i’m so there.
this was fun and fast paced. i did struggle to get into at first, but i eventually found myself sucked into the story. i definitely preferred the second half and the last 10% had me biting my nails in nervous anticipation.
the romance was good but i felt like it needed more depth. it started slow and then built up really quickly and i don’t know where their feelings came from. everything else was amazing! i really enjoyed the friendships the girls formed throughout their time together and the trials they went through were interesting.
i love the direction it went and will without a doubt be gnawing at the bars of my enclosure for a second book🙂↕️
January 9, 2025
4.5⭐️ | TikTok | IG |
This was a quick read, I finished it in a single sitting!
That ending!? STFU and give me the next book right MEOW!
For once I agree wholeheartedly with the title comps…
This has some of the beloved elements from many of our favs, The Selection (a competition to marry the prince), Cruel Prince (political scheming, plots, and trickster fae), Bridgerton (regency era London).
This was an excellent YA fantasy romance!
What’s to love…
- Faeries/Fae of the folklore variety
- (slight) Love triangle
- political scheming
- reimagined regency era London
- THE TWISTS, THE PLOT REVEALS!?
- cruel competition to marry the prince
- FMC that will do anything to protect her family
- themes of friendship and family
- I HATE trials, why did I pick this book?! knowing there are trials?! idk I’m not perfect... BUT I totally didn’t mind the trials in this one! They don’t drag on and fit the theme of the book and the nasty Queen perfectly!
What’s not to love…
- personally I thought the pacing was just a hair off, but I’m fairly certain that’s more of a me problem. It felt like it dragged a bit and then the ending was SO intense! That said please recall that I finished this in one sitting!
A note to mature readers…
- This is a YA book, and while I absolutely had a blast reading it I think it might not be quite as fun for adult readers who are borderline fans of YA literature. The romance + the actions of this book fit the age and maturity level of the MCs (18). I will say that this book does NOT suffer from the dreaded over explanation that is sometimes found in YA literature.
🌶️ - This is YA, so there is no explicit content. There is however one scene where non-explicit love-making happens (Ch 29). Publisher website rates this ages 13+. I’d let my mature middle school niece read this.
Thank you NetGalley and Harper Collins for sending this book (eARC) for review consideration. All opinions are my own.
This was a quick read, I finished it in a single sitting!
That ending!? STFU and give me the next book right MEOW!
For once I agree wholeheartedly with the title comps…
This has some of the beloved elements from many of our favs, The Selection (a competition to marry the prince), Cruel Prince (political scheming, plots, and trickster fae), Bridgerton (regency era London).
This was an excellent YA fantasy romance!
What’s to love…
- Faeries/Fae of the folklore variety
- (slight) Love triangle
- political scheming
- reimagined regency era London
- THE TWISTS, THE PLOT REVEALS!?
- cruel competition to marry the prince
- FMC that will do anything to protect her family
- themes of friendship and family
- I HATE trials, why did I pick this book?! knowing there are trials?! idk I’m not perfect... BUT I totally didn’t mind the trials in this one! They don’t drag on and fit the theme of the book and the nasty Queen perfectly!
What’s not to love…
- personally I thought the pacing was just a hair off, but I’m fairly certain that’s more of a me problem. It felt like it dragged a bit and then the ending was SO intense! That said please recall that I finished this in one sitting!
A note to mature readers…
- This is a YA book, and while I absolutely had a blast reading it I think it might not be quite as fun for adult readers who are borderline fans of YA literature. The romance + the actions of this book fit the age and maturity level of the MCs (18). I will say that this book does NOT suffer from the dreaded over explanation that is sometimes found in YA literature.
🌶️ - This is YA, so there is no explicit content. There is however one scene where non-explicit love-making happens (Ch 29). Publisher website rates this ages 13+. I’d let my mature middle school niece read this.
Thank you NetGalley and Harper Collins for sending this book (eARC) for review consideration. All opinions are my own.
March 11, 2025
Sasha Peyton Smith manages to weave a story of trickery and tangled emotions in The Rose Bargain. Faerie lore is by far my favourite, and you can tell this book takes joy in playing with its parameters. With the marriage trial trope keeping the pages turning and a wealth of emotion described in ways that cut straight to your soul, it’s hard not to get entangled in this story.
January 27, 2025
Thank you to the author and HarperCollins Children's Books | HarperCollins for sending me this ARC! 💕✨👑🌹
When I say this book swept me away, I truly mean that I found myself completely immersed in its captivating narrative. The story possesses a delightful whimsy, interwoven with intriguing layers of mystery that kept me eagerly turning the pages. The plot unfolds with a magic system that feels both unique and believable, drawing me deeper into its world. The characters are richly developed, each with their own quirks and depths, and the unexpected twists add an extra edge. Everything about this story—from its enchanting prose to its intricate details—was nothing short of exceptional. Absolutely blown away. I never wanted this story to end, and I am so eager for the second book in this series. I already want to re-read this one.
What to expect:
🌹Fae / Human Worlds
🌹Royalty
🌹Bargains, Trials, + Competition
🌹Political Agendas/Scheming
🌹Love Triangle
🌹Young Adult - Fantasy
This will undoubtedly be a book to look out for this year. Add it to your TBR now; if you haven't already, you need to preorder it. So many beautiful special editions are being crafted for this one. I cannot wait to get my hands on one come publication day.
p.s. GoodReads is also doing a giveaway right now, so make sure you enter!!!
Pub Day: 04 February 2025
And as always, all thoughts are my own. 🖤✨
When I say this book swept me away, I truly mean that I found myself completely immersed in its captivating narrative. The story possesses a delightful whimsy, interwoven with intriguing layers of mystery that kept me eagerly turning the pages. The plot unfolds with a magic system that feels both unique and believable, drawing me deeper into its world. The characters are richly developed, each with their own quirks and depths, and the unexpected twists add an extra edge. Everything about this story—from its enchanting prose to its intricate details—was nothing short of exceptional. Absolutely blown away. I never wanted this story to end, and I am so eager for the second book in this series. I already want to re-read this one.
What to expect:
🌹Fae / Human Worlds
🌹Royalty
🌹Bargains, Trials, + Competition
🌹Political Agendas/Scheming
🌹Love Triangle
🌹Young Adult - Fantasy
This will undoubtedly be a book to look out for this year. Add it to your TBR now; if you haven't already, you need to preorder it. So many beautiful special editions are being crafted for this one. I cannot wait to get my hands on one come publication day.
p.s. GoodReads is also doing a giveaway right now, so make sure you enter!!!
Pub Day: 04 February 2025
And as always, all thoughts are my own. 🖤✨
March 1, 2025
okay so basically the last 10% was me just saying WHAT?! repeatedly because truly that took a turn i did not expect at all. its killing me not to say anything and maybe it was obvious but i genuinely didnt see that situation coming.
overall though this was definitely a book worth reading!! although it couldve helped that i went in with absolutely zero expectations because i requested this on netgalley on impulse so? but im glad i did because i had so much fun!! the trials were absolutely insane in the most crazy and interesting ways, im so used to fae in most books not being that scary (or the FMC just isnt scared of them) but here? oh theyre definitely *fae*... i actually kind of wish we got more of the trials but also its not a huge complaint because what we got was really good!!
honestly my favourite part of this book had to be that ending (of course) and the girls competing against one another to be bram's bride and their relationship with one another!! 1) it was so funny, and 2) it took a surprising turn that i really liked and i very much hope that this is explored more in book 2? although with the way book 2 is set up i dont think thats as likely but hopefully im wrong!
and then the romance !! okay so i will say that even though it couldve been developed a little more, THE ANGST?? THE LONGING?? omg. the having to share a room at an inn because they had no choice... the way they convince one another it means nothing😭 that whole scene was so >>>
also i could NOT stop picturing the MMC as one of those sad lost puppies with big eyes staring at you, truly he's so sweet. i liked the FMC's personality (though she did irk me at times with her decisions) but honestly i have to say after a certain point im soo curious about the FMC's sister, i need more than what we got !!
this was such a fast-paced and enjoyable read, i cant wait for the 2nd book (which will be awhile considering im reading an ARC of this💔) that ending really was insane!! I do wish it wasn't as rushed with all those plot twists (like for example getting the story we wanted behind someone) but I so need to know what happens in the next book ASAP
Thank you HarperCollins for sending me an ARC via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review!
overall though this was definitely a book worth reading!! although it couldve helped that i went in with absolutely zero expectations because i requested this on netgalley on impulse so? but im glad i did because i had so much fun!! the trials were absolutely insane in the most crazy and interesting ways, im so used to fae in most books not being that scary (or the FMC just isnt scared of them) but here? oh theyre definitely *fae*... i actually kind of wish we got more of the trials but also its not a huge complaint because what we got was really good!!
honestly my favourite part of this book had to be that ending (of course) and the girls competing against one another to be bram's bride and their relationship with one another!! 1) it was so funny, and 2) it took a surprising turn that i really liked and i very much hope that this is explored more in book 2? although with the way book 2 is set up i dont think thats as likely but hopefully im wrong!
and then the romance !! okay so i will say that even though it couldve been developed a little more, THE ANGST?? THE LONGING?? omg. the having to share a room at an inn because they had no choice... the way they convince one another it means nothing😭 that whole scene was so >>>
also i could NOT stop picturing the MMC as one of those sad lost puppies with big eyes staring at you, truly he's so sweet. i liked the FMC's personality (though she did irk me at times with her decisions) but honestly i have to say after a certain point im soo curious about the FMC's sister, i need more than what we got !!
this was such a fast-paced and enjoyable read, i cant wait for the 2nd book (which will be awhile considering im reading an ARC of this💔) that ending really was insane!! I do wish it wasn't as rushed with all those plot twists (like for example getting the story we wanted behind someone) but I so need to know what happens in the next book ASAP
Thank you HarperCollins for sending me an ARC via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review!
March 3, 2025
Ooo this was a great mix of fantasy and historical fiction with your typical fae world. The Rose Bargain will spark some really interesting conversations about the presence of physical intimacy in YA novels. While I won't get into that discussion here, I think that Smith wrote this in a way that is appropriate for a YA audience and it illustrated the connection between two characters.
What Worked: I'm not sure I've read many YA novels that tap into both historical fiction and fantasy; however, Smith did a great job blending a host of genres. Not only was I pulled into the idea of a Fae queen taking over the English monarchy, but I was completely enthralled with the characters. Having a wide cast of characters is risky in some ways. While it provides the narrative with a broad range of perspectives and interactions for the main character, the author must be able to create distinctive, unique personalities. Not a single character read the same way. And Smith gives us a taste of quite a few characters and their motivations for entering the competition. It was skillful and intentional with major implications. THAT TWIST AT THE END HAD MY JAW UNHINGED. It was COMPLETELY unexpected. I cannot wait to see how all of this plays out in book 2.
What Didn't Work: I think that parts of this didn't always read YA, but I definitely can see it working for an older YA audience. Also, there were some things that I've seen in other YA fantasies, but that's to be expected.
Overall, this was a great read! I'm definitely looking forward to checking out the sequel when it releases.
What Worked: I'm not sure I've read many YA novels that tap into both historical fiction and fantasy; however, Smith did a great job blending a host of genres. Not only was I pulled into the idea of a Fae queen taking over the English monarchy, but I was completely enthralled with the characters. Having a wide cast of characters is risky in some ways. While it provides the narrative with a broad range of perspectives and interactions for the main character, the author must be able to create distinctive, unique personalities. Not a single character read the same way. And Smith gives us a taste of quite a few characters and their motivations for entering the competition. It was skillful and intentional with major implications. THAT TWIST AT THE END HAD MY JAW UNHINGED. It was COMPLETELY unexpected. I cannot wait to see how all of this plays out in book 2.
What Didn't Work: I think that parts of this didn't always read YA, but I definitely can see it working for an older YA audience. Also, there were some things that I've seen in other YA fantasies, but that's to be expected.
Overall, this was a great read! I'm definitely looking forward to checking out the sequel when it releases.
February 28, 2025
4.5 ⭐️ Books like this are why I love YA fantasy!! This book very much gave The Cruel Prince x The Selection x Bridgerton and I ate up every page. The world was fascinating, whimsical, and magical and I loved being in this setting. The political side of the story was also engaging and low key had me stressed. The premise was fun and entertaining and I was never bored. The story was constantly entertaining and I was on the edge of my seat wondering where things could be going. I absolutely loved the female friendship dynamics and their character growth together. The romance 😭 the romance was so good with the tension and the yearning and the secrecy of it all. I was rooting for them so hard and was so scared of what could happen. Maybe I should’ve expected the plot twist at the end but I didn’t and it has me ACHING for book 2!!! I’m so distraught that I thought this was a standalone. Loved every aspect of this story and can’t wait to continue.
February 12, 2025
Girl-
Ummm wow the last three chapters were definitely a whirlwind that has me staring at my wall for a two minutes.
The way that I thought this book was going to end it took a whole turn.🫥
This book is if out of nowhere a Fae Queen went to England and stole the crown from King Charles through a bargain.
This story follows Ivy who enters a competition for the hand in marriage to the prince of the Fae Queen in order to restore her family's image.
With the help from the prince's brother Emmett who is secretly in love with her but they have to focus on taking down the Fae Queen who in the end we come to see isn't even the real evil in this book💀
I loved the fact that each of the other five girls had a chapter pov so that we got to know them better and why they got into the competition.
This book also has the one bed trope 🤭✨
The story consumed me and I'm not mad about it and I can't wait for the 2nd book to come out. It better be soon though😭
Ummm wow the last three chapters were definitely a whirlwind that has me staring at my wall for a two minutes.
The way that I thought this book was going to end it took a whole turn.🫥
This book is if out of nowhere a Fae Queen went to England and stole the crown from King Charles through a bargain.
This story follows Ivy who enters a competition for the hand in marriage to the prince of the Fae Queen in order to restore her family's image.
With the help from the prince's brother Emmett who is secretly in love with her but they have to focus on taking down the Fae Queen who in the end we come to see isn't even the real evil in this book💀
I loved the fact that each of the other five girls had a chapter pov so that we got to know them better and why they got into the competition.
This book also has the one bed trope 🤭✨
The story consumed me and I'm not mad about it and I can't wait for the 2nd book to come out. It better be soon though😭
December 14, 2024
As always, thanks to HarperCollins for sending me this ARC. This was one of the ARCs I was crossing my fingers and toes to have sent to me!
Bridgerton + The Cruel Prince + The Selection...romantasy...enemies to lovers...fae...does it get any better than that!?
I'm pretty sure this book checked every single box of a perfect YA story! I stayed awake til 4am flipping the pages, I couldn't close my yes until I was finished. I absolutely can not wait for the next book because the plot only gets juicier!
There were 2 things that kept this from being a 5 star for me. The first was the imagery wasn't as vivid as I would have liked. I could kind of picture everything but it took a little effort. The second was the singular chapters that the other girls got thru out the story. I don't think any of those chapters helped me to understand those characters any different because everything was beautifully told or found out thru discussions amongst the girls. Those chapters were quite short tho so it didn't keep me from the exciting stuff for too long.
Bridgerton + The Cruel Prince + The Selection...romantasy...enemies to lovers...fae...does it get any better than that!?
I'm pretty sure this book checked every single box of a perfect YA story! I stayed awake til 4am flipping the pages, I couldn't close my yes until I was finished. I absolutely can not wait for the next book because the plot only gets juicier!
There were 2 things that kept this from being a 5 star for me. The first was the imagery wasn't as vivid as I would have liked. I could kind of picture everything but it took a little effort. The second was the singular chapters that the other girls got thru out the story. I don't think any of those chapters helped me to understand those characters any different because everything was beautifully told or found out thru discussions amongst the girls. Those chapters were quite short tho so it didn't keep me from the exciting stuff for too long.
March 22, 2025
4.5⭐️ rounded up!!
OH THIS BOOK GRABBED ME BY THE THROAT AND DID NOT LET GO.
This was the perfect combination of The Selection, Bridgerton, Cruel Prince, and Once Upon a Broken Heart, and it completely whisked me away. The way I FLEW through this book! It was so unique and atmospheric - think high society in Victorian era London, but make it magical and whimsical✨
I absolutely loved the forbidden romance and the love triangle vibes in this book - that combined with the plotting and scheming, the competition/games, the POV changes, the themes of female friendships and solidarity - I could not put it down! The only reason I didn’t give this 5 stars was because I would’ve loved a bit more development with the romance plot line.
Now that ending had me sitting up straight in bed at 2 am BECAUSE BOY DID THE PLOT THICKEN, and I did not see it coming🫨 That ending set book 2 up perfectly and I CANNOT WAIT.
Definitely a new YA favorite for me!!!
OH THIS BOOK GRABBED ME BY THE THROAT AND DID NOT LET GO.
This was the perfect combination of The Selection, Bridgerton, Cruel Prince, and Once Upon a Broken Heart, and it completely whisked me away. The way I FLEW through this book! It was so unique and atmospheric - think high society in Victorian era London, but make it magical and whimsical✨
I absolutely loved the forbidden romance and the love triangle vibes in this book - that combined with the plotting and scheming, the competition/games, the POV changes, the themes of female friendships and solidarity - I could not put it down! The only reason I didn’t give this 5 stars was because I would’ve loved a bit more development with the romance plot line.
Now that ending had me sitting up straight in bed at 2 am BECAUSE BOY DID THE PLOT THICKEN, and I did not see it coming🫨 That ending set book 2 up perfectly and I CANNOT WAIT.
Definitely a new YA favorite for me!!!
March 1, 2025
Absolutely. Obsessed.
Definitely for fans of Cruel Prince/Bridgerton/Buccaneers/and all things faerie and whimsical!
I can’t even express how much of a chokehold this book had on me for the last 24 hours. Cannot WAIT for book two!
Definitely for fans of Cruel Prince/Bridgerton/Buccaneers/and all things faerie and whimsical!
I can’t even express how much of a chokehold this book had on me for the last 24 hours. Cannot WAIT for book two!
February 28, 2025
4.5 stars rounded up
Magical bargains and a competition for the hand of a fae prince, but with an approach that feels fresh. The Rose Bargain surprised me in the best way. I feel like this kind of book can sometimes feel like something we've seen before, but while it has the hallmarks of the genre (dangerous bargains, forbidden romance, twisted fae games) it also does things differently. For one, the young women in the competition are mostly supportive of one another rather than tearing each other down. Instead, the villain of the story is the cruel fae queen who puts them through horrible challenges. It's a refreshing change for the subgenre to recognize that what's really messed up is the systems that made these women feel the need to compete in the first place.
This is a historical fantasy sent in England, but where a fae queen took over years ago and has disconnected them from the larger world. Every debutante has the chance to make a bargain with the queen for something she wants, but the price might be higher than she realizes. This year though, the queen announces that her son Prince Bram will be seeking a bride. Ivy will do anything to save her family after the disgrace of her sister disappearing for years before returning with no memory of what happened to her. But while Ivy is competing for Bram's hand in marriage, she feels far more drawn to his step-brother...
I was impressed with how good this was, and that it didn't do quite what I expected. The book leaves off with an explosive ending and a cliffhanger that makes me anxious for book 2. I received a copy of this book for review from the publisher, all opinions are my own.
Magical bargains and a competition for the hand of a fae prince, but with an approach that feels fresh. The Rose Bargain surprised me in the best way. I feel like this kind of book can sometimes feel like something we've seen before, but while it has the hallmarks of the genre (dangerous bargains, forbidden romance, twisted fae games) it also does things differently. For one, the young women in the competition are mostly supportive of one another rather than tearing each other down. Instead, the villain of the story is the cruel fae queen who puts them through horrible challenges. It's a refreshing change for the subgenre to recognize that what's really messed up is the systems that made these women feel the need to compete in the first place.
This is a historical fantasy sent in England, but where a fae queen took over years ago and has disconnected them from the larger world. Every debutante has the chance to make a bargain with the queen for something she wants, but the price might be higher than she realizes. This year though, the queen announces that her son Prince Bram will be seeking a bride. Ivy will do anything to save her family after the disgrace of her sister disappearing for years before returning with no memory of what happened to her. But while Ivy is competing for Bram's hand in marriage, she feels far more drawn to his step-brother...
I was impressed with how good this was, and that it didn't do quite what I expected. The book leaves off with an explosive ending and a cliffhanger that makes me anxious for book 2. I received a copy of this book for review from the publisher, all opinions are my own.
February 4, 2025
happy pub day to this fool 😭
there’s nothing inherently wrong with this at all, i’m just not invested. it was marketed as the selection x the cruel prince x the bachelor, which like yes it is so if that’s your vibe, more power to ya! i’m just sitting here trying to force myself to finish it but the world building/relationships weren’t worth investing in at the moment 😭
thank you to netgalley and the publisher for an arc!!
there’s nothing inherently wrong with this at all, i’m just not invested. it was marketed as the selection x the cruel prince x the bachelor, which like yes it is so if that’s your vibe, more power to ya! i’m just sitting here trying to force myself to finish it but the world building/relationships weren’t worth investing in at the moment 😭
thank you to netgalley and the publisher for an arc!!
February 16, 2025
3.5 Stars
That ending 👀
Kinda struggled to get into this one at first.
It was very sweet, which isn’t really what i look for in fantasy.
That being said i found the story and the pacing to be interesting enough that i continued.
anyways, I am glad i did. I was initially think of giving a 3 star review, but that ending was honestly unexpected. To the point i am now hoping for book 2.
The only thing I really disagree with is the comparisons to Bridgerton. The only this that makes this comparable is that they are set in similar locations in similar time periods. The story, characters, plot and especially the lack of spice make the two incomparable.
That ending 👀
Kinda struggled to get into this one at first.
It was very sweet, which isn’t really what i look for in fantasy.
That being said i found the story and the pacing to be interesting enough that i continued.
anyways, I am glad i did. I was initially think of giving a 3 star review, but that ending was honestly unexpected. To the point i am now hoping for book 2.
The only thing I really disagree with is the comparisons to Bridgerton. The only this that makes this comparable is that they are set in similar locations in similar time periods. The story, characters, plot and especially the lack of spice make the two incomparable.
February 11, 2025
This book started strong but ultimately left me feeling disappointed. It was pretty much a slippery slope; the beginning was the high point and it went downhill pretty fast from there.
The start of the book was definitely its strongest point. The pacing was fast, and I found myself easily swept up in the story. I also really appreciated the regency-inspired atmosphere, which added a unique charm and helped set the stage for an intriguing world. Another one of the highlights for me was the side characters. I enjoyed how we got to learn their stories, which added depth to the overall narrative and made the world feel more expansive.
Unfortunately, the trials—one of the story's selling points—didn’t live up to expectations. They lacked tension and stakes, which made them feel like a chore to get through and whenever a trial began, I found myself wishing it would end quickly. It’s a shame because they had so much potential to bring excitement and depth to the story.
Even so, I was confident this would at least be a solid three-star read. But as the middle started wrapping up, things began to go off the rails. Relationships that felt barely developed were suddenly filled with “I love yous,” which made them hard to believe. The emotional weight just wasn’t there, and so all the confessions felt like more of a head scratchers than the usual satisfied feeling you get when characters admit their feelings for each other.
By the time I reached the ending, the story had gone so far off the rails that they weren’t even in sight anymore. The pacing became frantic, jumping from one scene to the next so quickly that nothing had a chance to resonate. Worse than that though, the plot took a predictable turn—the exact one I hoped it wouldn’t—which made the final twist feel underwhelming and, honestly, pretty eye roll worthy.
Not to mention there was a good old memory loss plot chucked in for no apparent reason other than to shock readers and create five minutes of angst before being resolved. That honestly should have been scraped completely because the story really needed the time to focus on the other things it was trying to pull off.
Overall, this book had a lot of potential, but it just couldn’t stick the landing. While I enjoyed the beginning and some parts of the middle, the story ultimately lost its way in favor of a twist I think I’ve seen attempted more times than I can count. If you’re drawn to the regency vibe or quick pacing, it might still be worth checking out, but for me, it fell short, and I’m honestly not interested in where the story will go from here as of now.
Thank you to Netgalley for providing me with an e-arc in exchange for an honest review!
~🅞🅥🅔🅡🅐🅛🅛 🅡🅐🅣🅘🅝🅖: ★ ★ ☆ ☆ ☆ . 75~
The start of the book was definitely its strongest point. The pacing was fast, and I found myself easily swept up in the story. I also really appreciated the regency-inspired atmosphere, which added a unique charm and helped set the stage for an intriguing world. Another one of the highlights for me was the side characters. I enjoyed how we got to learn their stories, which added depth to the overall narrative and made the world feel more expansive.
Unfortunately, the trials—one of the story's selling points—didn’t live up to expectations. They lacked tension and stakes, which made them feel like a chore to get through and whenever a trial began, I found myself wishing it would end quickly. It’s a shame because they had so much potential to bring excitement and depth to the story.
Even so, I was confident this would at least be a solid three-star read. But as the middle started wrapping up, things began to go off the rails. Relationships that felt barely developed were suddenly filled with “I love yous,” which made them hard to believe. The emotional weight just wasn’t there, and so all the confessions felt like more of a head scratchers than the usual satisfied feeling you get when characters admit their feelings for each other.
By the time I reached the ending, the story had gone so far off the rails that they weren’t even in sight anymore. The pacing became frantic, jumping from one scene to the next so quickly that nothing had a chance to resonate. Worse than that though, the plot took a predictable turn—the exact one I hoped it wouldn’t—which made the final twist feel underwhelming and, honestly, pretty eye roll worthy.
Not to mention there was a good old memory loss plot chucked in for no apparent reason other than to shock readers and create five minutes of angst before being resolved. That honestly should have been scraped completely because the story really needed the time to focus on the other things it was trying to pull off.
Overall, this book had a lot of potential, but it just couldn’t stick the landing. While I enjoyed the beginning and some parts of the middle, the story ultimately lost its way in favor of a twist I think I’ve seen attempted more times than I can count. If you’re drawn to the regency vibe or quick pacing, it might still be worth checking out, but for me, it fell short, and I’m honestly not interested in where the story will go from here as of now.
Thank you to Netgalley for providing me with an e-arc in exchange for an honest review!
~🅞🅥🅔🅡🅐🅛🅛 🅡🅐🅣🅘🅝🅖: ★ ★ ☆ ☆ ☆ . 75~
March 14, 2025
4.5⭐️
The Rose Bargain swept me into a world where fae deals were as beautiful as they were treacherous, and I ended up being so captivated by it. The idea of trading pieces of yourself for talents and beauty was both fascinating and unsettling—especially as Ivy stepped into a deadly competition that was far more than it seemed.
The competition for Prince Bram’s hand was The Selection with sharper teeth, and the fae world was as enchanting as it was treacherous. Ivy wasn’t some wide-eyed debutante—she was clever, calculating, and willing to do just about anything to save her family. The court intrigue was sharp, the romance was brimming with tension, and the fae were just the right amount of alluring and terrifying. The romance was done so well, with a classic YA love triangle that didn't feel overwrought or tedious. It was so interesting to see Ivy's connections with both Bram and Emmett unfold over the course of the book.
The only reason this wasn't 5 stars for me was the beginning felt a bit slow and didn't immediately hook me. Otherwise, this book delivered exactly what I wanted: high-stakes romance, cunning rivals, and a touch of fae wickedness. I’ll definitely be grabbing the sequel!
The Rose Bargain swept me into a world where fae deals were as beautiful as they were treacherous, and I ended up being so captivated by it. The idea of trading pieces of yourself for talents and beauty was both fascinating and unsettling—especially as Ivy stepped into a deadly competition that was far more than it seemed.
The competition for Prince Bram’s hand was The Selection with sharper teeth, and the fae world was as enchanting as it was treacherous. Ivy wasn’t some wide-eyed debutante—she was clever, calculating, and willing to do just about anything to save her family. The court intrigue was sharp, the romance was brimming with tension, and the fae were just the right amount of alluring and terrifying. The romance was done so well, with a classic YA love triangle that didn't feel overwrought or tedious. It was so interesting to see Ivy's connections with both Bram and Emmett unfold over the course of the book.
The only reason this wasn't 5 stars for me was the beginning felt a bit slow and didn't immediately hook me. Otherwise, this book delivered exactly what I wanted: high-stakes romance, cunning rivals, and a touch of fae wickedness. I’ll definitely be grabbing the sequel!
February 6, 2025
Wow I am not exaggerating, this was EVERYTHING I wanted and more in a YA Romantasy! Definitely for fans of Cruel Prince, Once Upon a Broken Heart and Half a Soul! It is set in a lush rose-colored regency era mixed with the magic of Fae-- but underneath the glamour is a dark and twisty plot that had me binging this book in two days! AND THAT ENDING I totally went in thinking this was a standalone! This was my first book by this author and it won't be my last-- I will be thinking about this book and very much impatiently waiting for the next one in this series!
Thank you SO much NetGalley for this ARC. :)
Thank you SO much NetGalley for this ARC. :)
March 16, 2025
3.5⭐️ Super cute book with some crazy plot twists at the end! I loved Emmet so much 🥹 Excited for book 2 whenever it comes out.
January 26, 2025
⭐️ 4.5
Okay, this is so cute. The Rose Bargain is the perfect mix of sugary sweet and darkly magical. The prose was great and the setting is just realistic enough to keep you grounded but with that super fun fairy twist. I couldn't help but keep reading to find out what happened next! I really enjoyed the characters, their motives, and how, in particular, the girls interacted with each other. Sometimes these types of bachelor-esque competition books have cattiness between the female contestants that doesn't sit right with me and that's not there here. My only gripe is that the pacing of the romance did seem to stumble and then go too quickly towards the middle but that's a minor nitpick. Otherwise it was a delightful and suspenseful romance with the Bridgerton-like drama you'd expect from the synopsis. Also...there's an intense cliffhanger so I'm very excited for the next book in the series as well!
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Okay, this is so cute. The Rose Bargain is the perfect mix of sugary sweet and darkly magical. The prose was great and the setting is just realistic enough to keep you grounded but with that super fun fairy twist. I couldn't help but keep reading to find out what happened next! I really enjoyed the characters, their motives, and how, in particular, the girls interacted with each other. Sometimes these types of bachelor-esque competition books have cattiness between the female contestants that doesn't sit right with me and that's not there here. My only gripe is that the pacing of the romance did seem to stumble and then go too quickly towards the middle but that's a minor nitpick. Otherwise it was a delightful and suspenseful romance with the Bridgerton-like drama you'd expect from the synopsis. Also...there's an intense cliffhanger so I'm very excited for the next book in the series as well!
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
February 25, 2025
firstly, thank you to the publisher for an arc!
i find i prefer faerie stories when they are not the glamorous sjmaas kind (despite having a soft spot for the beautiful and lethal fae). i love when they are more traditionally cunning and sneaky, especially with their bargains.
very excited to read book two!
i find i prefer faerie stories when they are not the glamorous sjmaas kind (despite having a soft spot for the beautiful and lethal fae). i love when they are more traditionally cunning and sneaky, especially with their bargains.
very excited to read book two!
August 27, 2024
Y'ALLLLLLL.
This is the YA fantasy high I've been chasing for a while. It was described as The Cruel Prince meets Bridgerton (which like, sign me UP) but it's so much more than that. Peyton Smith takes the concept of Bachelor Nation, unhinged in it's own right, and turns it into something dark. Queen Mor's "challenges" honestly were not that far off from some of the challenges I've seen on the show. Not to give anything away, but there's a maypole scene reminiscent of the disgusting and humiliating cured meat maypole in Joey's season (LOL). I also enjoyed the friendship's that developed in the "house". This is everything I wanted The Selection to be (don't at me). The love triangle is light, the male main character is *chef's kiss* and this is a fresh take on a fae fairy tale. I highly recommend this and will be adding it to our library's order list as soon as we're back to school next week.
Thank you to Edelweiss and Harper Collins for the opportunity to read and review!
This is the YA fantasy high I've been chasing for a while. It was described as The Cruel Prince meets Bridgerton (which like, sign me UP) but it's so much more than that. Peyton Smith takes the concept of Bachelor Nation, unhinged in it's own right, and turns it into something dark. Queen Mor's "challenges" honestly were not that far off from some of the challenges I've seen on the show. Not to give anything away, but there's a maypole scene reminiscent of the disgusting and humiliating cured meat maypole in Joey's season (LOL). I also enjoyed the friendship's that developed in the "house". This is everything I wanted The Selection to be (don't at me). The love triangle is light, the male main character is *chef's kiss* and this is a fresh take on a fae fairy tale. I highly recommend this and will be adding it to our library's order list as soon as we're back to school next week.
Thank you to Edelweiss and Harper Collins for the opportunity to read and review!
Currently reading
March 22, 2025The cover is everything
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,157 reviews